Picking one winner from a list is simple — anyone can click a button once. The problem shows up the moment a giveaway has more than one prize. Draw the same list a second time with an ordinary random picker and there's nothing stopping the first winner from being pulled again, which means either an awkward manual re-draw or, worse, a legitimate complaint from everyone watching that the "random" draw just picked the same person twice. PickerToolbox has three features built specifically to solve this, and most people never find them because they're tucked into a settings panel rather than front and center. Here's exactly how to use each one.
Why a single-pick tool breaks down for multi-prize draws
A basic random picker treats every click as an independent event — it has no memory of who it already chose. For a one-winner giveaway that's exactly right. For a three-prize giveaway, it means you're one careless click away from announcing the same winner twice, then having to explain to everyone watching why you're "re-rolling" a result that was supposed to be final. The fix isn't a smarter random number generator; it's a picker that remembers who's already won and automatically takes them out of the pool before the next draw.
Raffle mode: sequential draws with no repeats
Open the List Picker and turn on Raffle mode in the settings panel. This switches the tool from a single stateless pick to a sequential draw: click Pick once for first prize, and that winner is automatically removed from the pool before you click Pick again for second prize. There's no way to draw the same name twice across the session, because by the time you draw again, that name is no longer in the list. The history panel logs every result as you go, so if someone asks "wait, who won the second prize again?" five minutes later, you have a visible record rather than relying on memory.
Raffle mode is the right choice when your prizes are different from each other — first prize, second prize, a few runner-up prizes — and you want the suspense of drawing them one at a time, in order, in front of an audience.
Pick N winners: drawing a batch all at once
If your prizes are identical — say, five people are each getting the same gift card — you don't need the drama of a sequential draw. Instead, use the "Pick N winner(s)" field on the List Picker: set it to 5, click Pick once, and all five winners are selected simultaneously. No name can appear twice within that single draw, so you get your full batch of non-repeating winners in one click instead of five separate ones. This is faster than Raffle mode for identical-prize giveaways, but it won't give you an ordered reveal — all five names appear at once rather than one at a time.
Remove winner: the same idea, but visual
Running the draw on a livestream or a projector in front of a room changes what you need. A list of names disappearing from a panel is far less watchable than a wheel losing a slice. For that, use the Wheel Spinner instead of the List Picker, and turn on "Remove winner" in its settings. Every time the wheel lands on a name, that segment disappears before the next spin, so the wheel visibly shrinks with each prize awarded. It's functionally identical to Raffle mode — no repeat winners — but it reads better on screen, which matters a lot if you're drawing winners live on Twitch, YouTube, or a classroom projector.
Giving some entrants a better shot: weighted entries
Multi-prize giveaways often come with tiered entries — someone who referred a friend, tagged three people, or bought two raffle tickets instead of one should have a better chance of winning than someone with a single entry, without you having to retype their name multiple times. Toggle on Advanced mode on the Wheel Spinner and set a custom weight per entry: a weight of 2 makes that entry twice as likely to be picked as a standard weight-1 entry, and it combines with Remove winner normally, so weighting only affects that one draw rather than piling up an advantage across every remaining prize.
Pro tip: Before you draw, use the Share button to turn your full entry list (and any weights) into a URL. Post that link publicly a few minutes before a live draw so entrants can check their name is spelled correctly and their weight is right — it heads off disputes before they happen instead of after you've already announced a winner.
A worked example: a three-prize livestream giveaway
Say you're drawing three prizes live on stream: a top prize, a runner-up prize, and a third consolation prize, from a list of 80 viewer names. Paste all 80 names into the Wheel Spinner, turn on Remove winner, and spin once for the top prize — the winner's segment disappears automatically. Spin again for the runner-up from the remaining 79 names, then once more for the third prize from 78. Three spins, three distinct winners, no manual editing of the list between draws, and the shrinking wheel gives viewers a visual sense of how many people are still in the running before each spin.
Ready to draw multiple winners? Open the Wheel Spinner, paste your entrants, and turn on Remove winner before your first spin.
Open the Wheel Spinner →Frequently asked questions
How do I pick multiple winners from the same giveaway list?
Use the List Picker's "Pick N winner(s)" field to draw several winners at once — nobody can be picked twice in that single draw. If you want the drama of drawing one prize at a time instead, turn on Raffle mode so each Pick removes the previous winner from the pool before the next draw.
What is Raffle mode?
Raffle mode is a setting in the List Picker that switches it to sequential draws. Each time you click Pick, the winner is automatically removed from the pool so the next draw can only select from people who haven't won yet, guaranteeing no repeat winners across multiple picks. The history panel logs every result as you go.
Does the Wheel Spinner have an equivalent to Raffle mode?
Yes — enable "Remove winner" in the Wheel Spinner's settings and the winning segment disappears from the wheel automatically after each spin. It's the same no-repeat logic as Raffle mode, but visual, which makes it a better fit for drawing multiple prizes live on a stream or projector.
Can I give some entrants a better chance of winning?
Yes, using Advanced mode on the Wheel Spinner. It lets you set a custom weight per entry — a weight of 2 makes that entry twice as likely to be picked as a standard weight-1 entry. This is useful for giveaways where some participants earned bonus entries, such as referrals or extra actions completed.
Is it fair to use a random picker for a giveaway with several prizes?
It's generally fairer than manual methods, since the draw uses cryptographically secure randomness rather than a method a host could consciously or unconsciously influence. Sharing your screen during the draw, and using the Share button to let entrants verify the exact entry list beforehand, makes the process fully transparent on top of being random.